Sun Oct 27 11:20:18 1996

From owner-tc-list  Sun Oct 27 11:20:18 1996
Return-Path: 
Received: by scholar.cc.emory.edu (SMI-8.6/SMI-SVR4)
	id LAA18447; Sun, 27 Oct 1996 11:17:58 -0500
From: "Professor L.W. Hurtado" 
Organization: Divinity Faculty
To: tc-list@scholar.cc.emory.edu
Date: Sun, 27 Oct 1996 16:13:20 +000
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-type: text/plain; charset=US-ASCII
Content-transfer-encoding: 7BIT
Subject: Re: E. C. Colwell--A Maverick?
Priority: normal
X-mailer: Pegasus Mail for Windows (v2.33)
Message-ID: <34718389A@div.ed.ac.uk>
Sender: owner-tc-list@scholar.cc.emory.edu
Precedence: bulk
Reply-To: tc-list@scholar.cc.emory.edu
content-length: 1474

Colwell was certainly no maverick.  He was one of the foremost 
text-critics produced in N. American this century, and his sense of 
clear method puts us all in is debt. 
In the passage cited, Colwell is not attacking the work of the Alands 
in toto, but quite specifically criticizing the UBS edition as to its 
severely limited textual apparatus, criticisms echoed by many others 
also.
That the UBS edition tends to mislead is evident from the widespread 
use of it by NT students & even scholars, who often seem to have no 
real idea of its limitations and intention--as a translation base for 
translators, and never as a scholarly text for textual analysis.
As for comparing the work of Aland & Colwell, to do such is rather 
pointless and rather like children on a playground ("my old man is 
better than your old man").  To be sure, the Alands have put us all 
in their debt with the many contributions from their Muenster 
Institute.  But, to be fair, a large part of the reason for the 
Alands' success is the financial backing behind the Institute.  If 
such resources were more readily available elsewhere, who knows what 
might be done in other places!
Contra Jim West, I rather doubt that Colwell's cogent analyses will 
slip beneath the waves of history quite as readily as he thinks.
Larry Hurtado
L. W. Hurtado
University of Edinburgh,
New College
Mound Place 
Edinburgh, Scotland EH1 2LX
Phone: 0131-650-8920
Fax: 0131-650-6579
E-mail:  L.Hurtado@ed.ac.uk

Back